Non-competitive agency and Luther’s experiential argument against virtue

Zahl, Simeon (2018) Non-competitive agency and Luther’s experiential argument against virtue. Modern Theology, 35 (2). pp. 199-222. ISSN 1468-0025

Full text not available from this repository.


This article examines a critique that has been levied against Martin Luther’s account of the passivity of the human agent in salvation, and his corresponding critique of Aristotelian and Scholastic accounts of virtue. According to Reinhard Hütter and Jennifer Herdt, among others, Luther’s theology of passivity is primarily the product of a philosophical failure to recognize that divine and human agency can be conceived in non-competitive terms. In what follows, I will demonstrate through close analysis of Luther’s arguments that this philosophical critique does not succeed in refuting Luther’s theology of passivity. This is because it fails to recognize that Luther’s view of human agency and his critique of virtue are based to a significant degree on a different kind of argument: namely, empirical reflection on the experience of sin, including especially experience of the unmasterability of sinful affections through discipline, habit, or effort of will. I conclude by arguing that until Christian virtue ethicists have reckoned with this experiential argument, they have not engaged with one of the strongest theological critiques of virtue-based paradigms of Christian moral transformation.

Item Type: Article
Additional Information: This is the peer reviewed version of the following article: Zahl, S. (2018), Non‐Competitive Agency and Luther's Experiential Argument Against Virtue. Modern Theology, 35, 199-222. doi:10.1111/moth.12410, which has been published in final form at This article may be used for non-commercial purposes in accordance with Wiley Terms and Conditions for Self-Archiving.
Schools/Departments: University of Nottingham, UK > Faculty of Arts > School of Humanities > Department of Theology and Religious Studies
Identification Number:
Depositing User: Eprints, Support
Date Deposited: 16 Jan 2018 15:07
Last Modified: 04 May 2020 19:33

Actions (Archive Staff Only)

Edit View Edit View